Wednesday, December 31, 2008
THE K2 TOP 40 WINES OF 2008
40. Chateau d’Epire Savennieres 2007. Thank you Kermit Lynch for delivering an extraordinary Chenin Blanc from the Loire. I really love this wine.
39. Sausal Zinfandel Old Vines 2006. A limited wonder. I wish I could get more of this wine.
38. Santa Ema Rivalta 2005. One powerful, dynamic Bordeaux-influenced Chilean red. Outstanding.
37. Chateau Fonreaud Listrac-Medoc 2005. One of the more affordable 2005s out there. A great intro to one of Bordeaux’s finest vintages ever.
36. Bodegas Borsao Monte Oton 2006 & 2007. Thank you Jorge Ordonez for delivering yet another exceptional value red. Voluptuous old vine Grenache for under $10. Really? I’m all over this one.
35. Chateau Suduiraut Sauternes 2005. It’s a Sauternes for crying out loud. And 2005? This is simply gorgeous.
34. Duval-Leroy Brut NV. Always one of the best Champagnes most of you have never had. Don’t expect me to keep this one a secret ever!
33. Domaine Faury St.-Joseph 2005. Another golden nugget in Kermit Lynch’s luminous portfolio. Amazing Northern Rhone wine.
32. Edmeades Zinfandel 2006. A fantastic Zin from Mendocino County. One of our hidden gems!
31. Olvena Chardonnay 2007. Extraordinary value in New World Chardonnay from the Somontano region of Spain. Delicious and well-made.
30. Girard Artistry 2003. Always a beautiful Bordeaux-styled red.
29. Lemelson Pinot Noir Thea’s Selection 2006. One of my favorite Oregon producers and one of my favorite Pinot Noirs.
28. Kermit Lynch Cotes-du-Rhone 2006. Really exquisite CDR for any price. Kermit Lynch is my hero!
27. Lorca Pinot Blanc 2005. I thought this would be old. WRONG! Damn, what a delicious, complex white wine, and from California no less.
26. Chateau Pey La Tour Bordeaux Superieur 2005. My go-to Bordeaux for under $20. One of Michel Rolland’s infinite projects. A terrific red wine.
25. Brundlmeyer Gruner-Veltliner Terrassen 2007. One of a host of amazing GruVe wines I tasted this year. Ageworthy, complex and balanced. An incredible white wine.
24. Kanonkop Pinotage 2004. I truly think this is the best Pinotage I have ever had.
23. Achaval-Ferrer Malbec 2007. A real surprise as usual! I love this producer, and their “entry-level” Malbec is remarkable. Really overdelivers.
22. Clos de los Siete 2006. Michel Rolland strikes again! Terrific Malbec blend. Amazing value!
21. Stoller Pinot Noir JV 2006. I love the youthful exuberance of this wine. Always a favorite, vintage after vintage.
20. Chateau St.-Georges St.Georges-St.Emilion 2004. Yes, it’s not a 2005, but if this producer delivers a stunning red wine in the classic-oriented 2004 vintage, just image their 2005. Look for it on next year’s list.
19. Hirsch Gruner-Veltliner “Veltliner #1” 2007 and First Drop First Love Red 2006. A tie of sorts. I love the Hirsch #1 for being a really dynamic white wine and the First Love Red as an extraordinary, unique medium-bodied red. I just couldn’t decide.
18. Educated Guess Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 & 2006. Really delivers on the promise of being top quality at an affordable price. I think I may truly enjoy Napa Valley Cab again thanks to these guys.
17. Foppiano Petite Sirah 2004 and Vincent Vignaud Pouilly-Fuisse 2005. Tie #2 – thanks to Jo Diaz of Juicy Tales for putting me back on the PS trail, as well as Louis Foppiano for coming by to reintroduce this yummy red to me and my staff. And the Vignaud PF is a terrific find – a Pouilly Fuisse that is as affordable as it is really good.
16. Columbia Crest Two Vines Vineyard 10 Red 2005 & 2006. Hands down the best damn value in our stores. Way to go Columbia Crest. You guys are awesome!
15. Bodegas Muga Reserva 2004. Scary good!
14. Luca Malbec 2007. One unbelievably amazing Malbec.
13. Seghesio Zinfandel Sonoma County 2007. The opine begins – WS already gave these guys more props than they should have – now we may witness the end of this wine being under $25. A shame, because this is the best f@#$ing Zin under $25, period!
12. Donnhoff Riesling QbA 2006 & 2007. I fell in love with this wine years ago, and it’s string of successes with not just me, but any self-respecting Riesling lover, continues.
11. L. Aubry Brut Ivoire et Ebene 2002. An amazing sparkler! Just remarkable.
10. Mendel Malbec 2006. This is one decadent red wine!
9. Vilmart et Cie Cuvee Rubis NV. Quite the sexy sparkler.
8. Papapietro Perry Pinot Noir Leras Vineyard 2006. One monster-bad-ass Pinot Noir from Russian River Valley’s best kept secret. A PN for Cab drinkers. Takes days to open up, years to fully mature in the bottle.
7. St. Supery Virtu 2006. An absolute stunner! My top white wine of 2008!
6. Pedestal Merlot 2005. More of that Michel Rolland mojo workin’ – an experience not to be missed.
5. Dei Sancta Catharina 2006. Extremely limited, delicious red blend from the truly gifted Catharina Dei, the queen of Prugnolo Gentile in Tuscany.
4. Two Angels Divinity 2005. A massive homage to Rhone grapes. Hedonistic, sexy, full-bodied love in a glass.
3. Chateau Beychevelle Saint-Julien 2005. I have become completely enthralled by Bordeaux, partly because of my new found love of Beychevelle.
2. Chateau Sociando-Mallet Haut-Medoc 2005. This overachieving unclassified Chateau should – if there is any justice in this world – become a classified growth. A hidden gem of the left bank!
1. Cellers Can Blau Mas de Can Blau 2005. This wine certainly wins the “Holy Sh#$” award for being so friggin’ good. Your palate will never truly be fulfilled until you taste this wine.
There are a lot of honorable mentions (more than I have time or room for) but a few of the standouts are: Waterbrook Reserve Syrah 2006, Heidi Schrock Muscat 2007, Chehalem 3 Vineyards Pinot Noir 2006, Sierra Cantabria Rioja Crianza 2004, Mulderbosch Rose 2008, Huia Sauvignon Blanc 2007, Star Lane Cabernet Sauvignon 2005, Fontanafredda Barbera Briccotondo 2007, Belle Vallee Willamette Valley Pinot Noir 2006, Domaine Lafond Chateauneuf-du-Pape 2005, Chateau Clerc-Milon Pauillac 2004, Marc Hebrart Brut Selection NV, MacRostie Syrah Wildcat Mountain 2004, and Terlano Pinot Grigio 2007.
We hope you have enjoyed our commentaries this year. We look forward to sharing a great many more tasting notes, diatribes and peculiar insights into this business in 2009.
Thank you and have a safe New Year!
Peace,
K2
Tuesday, December 30, 2008
GRAPE TREE STAFF TOP TEN OF 2008: JESSICA
1.) Mas Can Blau Montsant 2005
2.) Montes Alpha M 2004
3.) Descendientes Petalos 2006
4.) Caldwell Rocket Science 2006
5.) Craggy Range Martinborough Pinot Noir 2006
6.) Small Gully Mr. Black's Concoction Shiraz/Viogner 2005
7.) La Spinetta Barbera Ca di' Pian 2005
8.) Robert Weil Kabinett Halbtrocken 2006
9.) Trinoro Guardiola Chardonnay 2007
10.)Les Fiefs de Lagrange Saint Julien 2005
Monday, December 29, 2008
(Pop)Culture by Shannon
What really interests me, however, is the intersection between champagne (I’m using this word loosely now, meaning any sparkler) and culture. A symbol of wealth and power for centuries, champagne screams-I mean fizzes- luxury and indulgence, which is why it attracts so many people. For perhaps the first time I’ve noticed the way packaging may influence someone’s decision to buy, even more so with champagne than with any other bottle. The name on the bottle and the bottle itself are the sought after items, more so in some cases that what is inside.
Take for example the beautiful vintage Perrier-Jouet Fleur we have in the store, (1999), painted with delicate flowers and accompanied by two painted glasses. We have the upgraded (2000) Dom Perignon case, which opens in a modern way with a button on the bottom. Trendy Veuve Cliquot comes in a yellow travel case, also equipped with two glasses, made especially for the ultra-hip. And then there are the oddly understated Cristal bottles, simply wrapped in yellow cellophane. Moet Chandon will stud any bottle with Swarovski crystals to your liking for a pretty penny. (Like the ones given out at a marc jacobs show)
Although my eye and fancy is distracted momentarily by these proud peacocks displaying their feathers, my palate yearns for something more simplified. My favorites have to be the Domaine Carneros Brut and Brut Rose, both of which I’ve written about before. These Californian sparklers are elegant and have the perfect amount of fruit and fizziness, and are reasonably within budget. Delicate and delicious. After the carbonation goes to your head and a champagne high sets in, who need crystals, anyway?
GRAPE TREE STAFF TOP TEN OF 2008: COREY
Here be my Top 10:
Honorable Mentions:
Honorable Mentions for these two wines that we unfortunately will no longer carry.
Chateau Lepine => By far and away the best Bordeaux we carried for under 20 bucks.
Venta la Ossa => I love La Mancha tempranillos for their finish, and this was an exquisite example.
The Top Ten:
(10) Gysler Silvaner Halbtrocken => Wonderfully clean and crisp, absolutely perfect for sushi.
(9) Michele Picard Vouvray => I love chenin blanc from the Loire Valley, and this is a very nice and economical example of one. Good stone fruit and a touch of honey on the finish.
(8) Garnacha de Fuego => Old vine grenache from Spain, with spice notes to accompany Cajun, Thai, or any other spicy food.
(7) Pine Ridge Chenin Blanc/Viognier => I was at a dinner party at the Mount Adams Fish House, and was asked to recommend a white wine for everyone to share. All 12 people had ordered a very different fish dish, and this went with every one of them. A great find!
(6) Zisola Nero d’Avola => The only Italian (really Sicilian) on my list. Layer after layer to this wine, I would age it a few years.
(5) Borsao Red Wine => 75/25 blend of Grenache/Tempranillo, one of the best 7 dollar investments you can make in the wine world.
(4) Solanera => I use this wine as a bridge wine for people willing to explore out of California Cab and into Spain. It is Cab and Monastrell, with the fruit notes of a Napa Cab and the muscle of Monastrell. Does anyone remember the Disney movie Fantasia and the ballerina hippos? That’s what this wine encompasses…grace and power.
(3) Telegramme CDP => A rather “economical” (relatively) look at Chateauneuf du Pape with amazing depth and dark fruit notes, with the correct amount of earth for a French wine.
(2) Yellow Jersey Pinot Noir => I took the leap! I admit I was hesitant about a wine in a plastic bottle, but I made this my #2 wine for its surprise factor. I challenge anyone…pour this into a decanter and serve it to people without showing them the bottle. Tell them it’s a Pinot Noir, and ask them their opinion. Then tell them that it’s only 11 dollars and ask them their opinion again. Finally, show them the bottle. There is absolutely NO plastic taste, and if this came in a glass bottle it would have been over 20 dollars. By saving on shipping, the price is so much more affordable, giving us one of the best QPRs in the store. Note to those not familiar with wine lingo – QPR is Quality to Price Ratio. So long story short, don’t be a weenie about the plastic bottle and try this!
(1) Gaudium Gran Vino by Marques de Caceras => Simply sexy. If you buy this wine for me I will be your bestest friend.
Sunday, December 28, 2008
2008: THE YEAR IN REVIEW
1. Consolidation. The trade mags and suppliers do't really see what the big deal is with consolidation, but in the interests of customer service, it's everything. Consoldiation on the supplier side of things (such as Constellation ending up with Hogue, Mondavi, Toasted Head, and many others, and the overblown merger of Southcorp and Beringer Blass yielding Fosters Wine Estates (that's everything from Beringer, Chateau St. Jean, and Souverain, to Penfolds, Rosemount and Lindeman's)) it means certain brands leaving a well-established good working relationship with a trusted distributor to a murky, bureacratic mess with a more ambiguous, more monolithic distributor. Sometimes, the reverse has happened. Or even more remotely, a brand has ended up in a smaller house, one that is more focused, less diversified, and able to better provide both service to the brand and the customer (that would be us). The dirty little secret of the consolidation game is the problems it poses with the consumer's tier, that of the retailer, is one that we folks on this end have to deal with every day. And those suppliers (importers, wineries, brokerages) don't even care.
2. Exclusivities. Thanks to the economy taking a plunge, I think those suppliers relying so heavily on exclusive agreements with a sole retailer (like French importers Kysela, Kacher and Ex Cellars, along with wineries such as Graham Beck, Quilceda Creek and Bridgeview) may be reexamining their current business models. Consumers what to be able to comparison shop for everything, INCLUDING WINE, and that can't be done in the context of exclusivity. I've half a mind to tell these whenever they come calling to buy their wares, to take a big ol' flying leap, but it all revolves around what our customers want. If they want these wines, then we'll get them if we can. If they don't, there are plenty other wines in the sea.
3. Local Wineries. From the time I arrived here at LD in 2002 till now, the amount of local wineries has exploded. It's phenomenal, considering that the focus of KY farmers was primarily tobacco. Yet with the way tobacco products are perceived today, many of these tobacco farmers are turning to grapes, and many of them are making some really good wine. Across the river, wineries like Kinkead Ridge and Henke are doing extraordinary things, impressing critics all over the country and even the world. Pretty cool stuff.
4. Wine Blogging. The new generation of spreading the love, passion and knowledge of wine is now in the hands of Wine Bloggers around the world. Wineries such as Twisted Oak, Hahn, Stormhoek and Chateau Beaucastel, as well as respected writers like Eric Asimov of the NY Times and Steve Heimoff of Wine Enthusiast and the whole crew at Wine Spectator have embraced the new media. Local talent includes Michelle Lentz of My Wine Education, Tim Lemke of Cheap Wine Ratings, Mike Rosenberg of The Naked Vine, Jonathan Seeds of Best Drink Ever, and even up the road in Dayton, Ohio, renowned wine blogger Mark Fisher (the wine writer for the Dayton Daily News) have paved the way for an army of wine geeks (including us winos here at LD). We're all just at the ground floor, and it's only going to be one colossus of innovation.
5. Demand. Seems like everyone is drinking wine or at least trying wine these days. The desire to be more wine savvy is quite remarkable. And with so much information available these days, in print media, online, through tasting groups and various tasting events around town and throughout the country (and the world), it's no wonder wine continues to grow.
I am truly excited about what lies ahead in this industry. And 2009 promises to have even more remarkable surprises up its sleeve.
See you next year!
Saturday, December 27, 2008
GRAPE TREE STAFF TOP TEN OF 2008: ALFONSE
Rancho Zabaco Heritage Vines Zinfandel 2006. Chocolate, black cherry and pepper notes with a lush oak finish.
Murphy-Goode Liar’s Dice Zinfandel 2004. Dense and concentrated Zin with bright acidity that balances this beauty out.
Diseno Malbec 2007. Big, robust Malbec with blueberry and chocolate notes.
Sierra Cantabria Crianza 2004. Big, bold and fruity with heavy tannins and a big finish.
Bearboat Pinot Noir 2005. Strawberry, black cherry and cinnamon.
Pine Ridge Chenin Blanc/Viongier 2007. Soft, approachable white blend.
Riondo Prosecco NV. Crisp, lively sparkler with great balance acidity.
Chateau Ste. Michelle Chardonnay 2006. Butter, pear and apple with soft oak.
King Estate Pinot Gris 2007. Hints of lemon and pear with a spicy cinnamon finish.
Magito Sauvignon Blanc 2006. Bright lemon zest and tropical notes.
Cheers,
Alf
Friday, December 26, 2008
GRAPE TREE STAFF TOP TEN OF 2008: SHANNON
The highlights of my first 6 months in the wine business:
10)Honig Sauvignon Blanc 2007. I appreciate Michael Honig's family dedication to Cabernet Sauvignon and Sauvignon Blanc, and that dedication shows in this crisp and refreshing wine.
9)Dievole Pinocchio. A fruity and fun nero d'avola. It doesn't hurt that I drank this wine in the presence of Nick Lachey.
8)Venta la Ossa. I discover Spain! Well, Spanish wine that is.
7)Mischief and Mayhem Chablis 1er Cru 2006. This wine is a tribute to my discovery of really well-made Chardonnay, and my current obsession with anything Burgundian.
6)Merryvale Profile 2005. Wow. A big, powerful blend with finesse and style.
5) The Prisoner 2005. My first taste of this cult wine was out of a broken bottle off the delivery truck. Couldn't let it go to waste!
4) Chateau St. Martin de la Garrigue Blanc 2007. One of the most unique whites I've ever had, it definately stands out in my memory.
3) Domaine Carneros Brut Rose NV. Femininity in a glass. A fluted glass, that is.
2) Domaine Berthet-Rayne Chateauneuf-du-Pape 2006. A stunning representation of a chateauneuf, and the cutest wine making couple ever.
1) Cellar Can Blau Mas de Can Blau 2005. Even after palate fatigue of trying over 20 wines, this wine still managed to blow me away.
Wednesday, December 24, 2008
SHARING A TRADITION WITH YOU ALL
WOKE UP CHRISTMAS MORNING
Tossing and turning in my bed,
I could hear my wife grumbling dreamily:
"What's wrong with you?"
"I can't sleep," I tell her,
My hand gently rubbing her back
With clumsy reassurances.
Rising from bed,
The clock stares back at me
With its bright red eyes, shouting
"It's 2:45 in the blessed A.M.!"
Christmas morning.
Hmm...
I stumble through the bedroom door,
Creeping slightly, quietly down the stairs
Trying hard not to step on any of the seven cats
Scurrying around in the dark,
Those seven critters that call us pets while our backs are turned,
Ransacking our refrigerator
And running up our phone bill
While my wife and I are both at work.
Making my way downstairs,
And into the kitchen,
I look back at our Christmas tree
Standing silent and unlit.
Out through the windows I stare,
Gazing blindly at the patio,
The tree line behind it,
And the night sky above.
Like tiny crystals glistening in the streetlights,
I spy the first snow of winter.
It falls to the ground,
Deep and almost glowing,
As if ghostly angels
Rained phosphorous upon the Eatth
While we all lay asleep in our beds.
I mull over everything,
Like one gigantic epiphany,
Remembering the past with a skewed awe.
"Isn't it funny how everything I've done
And everyone I've known,
Has brought me to here, to this moment?"
All the people that have come and gone in my life,
Either by Death, Distance or Time,
All the wondrous places I've been,
And all the sorrow I have felt
Has delivered me soemwhere I never thought I'd be.
As the snow comes down,
I wonder how my family is doing,
Living their lives close by and far away,
The ones I haven't spoken to in years,
And the ones I spoke with only yesterday.
I pray they all are well,
And that they all are happy -
For the holidays,
And for always.
I smile as my mind finds my wife,
Who is sleeping sweetly above me,
Unaware of my nocturnal pondering.
Each day she reminds me of what life can be like,
When bad things lose their meaning,
And pain and suffering can be forgotten.
And suddenly it hits me -
Christmas is not about gifts,
It's not about money or parties,
Tacky Hallmark decorations or chaos in the shopping malls.
It's about love and family.
(If ever there was a corny moment, it's now.)
I am thankful for my family.
And I am thankful to have known love.
I whisper prayers within the darkness:
A prayer for forgiveness
For those I may have wronged.
A prayer of remembrance
For the ones I have lost along the way.
A prayer of thankfulness
For those who still stand beside me each day
And a prayer of hope
To those still begrudged and distant.
I breathed and sighed,
And reached down for Kosmo,
My most comical of cats,
And the world of worry slipped away.
I made my way back upstairs,
Stumbling back to bed,
To dream of sugarplums,
Smiles,
And my family.
"Merry Christmas to all," I quipped to no one,
"And to all a good night."
I muttered a few more prayers
And climbed into bed.
Looking over at my wife,
I took her sleepy hand,
And closed my eyes in a peaceful surrender
Listening to her breathing,
Dreams took over...
GRAPE TREE STAFF TOP TEN OF 2008: SEAN
My top 10 list of wines I have tried over the course of the year.
10) Hope Estate Shiraz 2006 "The Ripper". This little Shiraz from down under lived up to its name. It was a monster wine for under $15.
9) Justin Orphan 2006. A great wine from a great producer. I like that its a wine with a little mystery to it.
8) Domaine Pichot Vouvray 2007. Hands down the best all purpose white wine I had all year round. This goes great with just about anything you can think of.
7) Wild Oak Zinfandel 2005. Big full bodied zin with a nice cedar and spice undertone. Long and peppery finish. Just the way I like them.
6) Planeta Chardonnay 2006. All I can say is holy oak and butter that is the BIGGEST Chardonnay I have ever had. It was by far the best Chard I had all year.
5) Ridge Independence School 2003. Dug into the cellar a bit to pull this one out, but it was an incredible zin. Anything from Ridge is flat out good wine.
4) Montes Alpha M 2005. This is the premier wine from one of Chile's top producers. It was amazing, I actually drank it over a 2 day span.
3) Justin Cabernet Sauvignon 2005. Not only is it one of my favorite cabs, it was also the wine of choice for dinner for my fiance and I on the night of our engagement.
2) Chartogne Taillet NV Brut "Cuvee St.-Anne". For those of you that do not know I am a champagne freak. I love the bubbly and this was the best I had during the year.
1) Orin Swift The Prisoner 2005,2006,2007, etc. This is not only a top 10 wine of the year for me, it more of a top 3 wine of a life time. I love everything about this wine the blend is not your common blend, and it gives the wine a rich almost port like flavor. Lots of raspberry, spice, oak, cedar, and a silky smooth finish that seemingly last for ever. I'm getting thirsty just thinking about it. I hope everyone had a great year and that 2009 is even better.
Thanks For A Wonderful Year,
Sean Glossner
Tuesday, December 23, 2008
THE BEST AND THE WORST OF THE KY WINE BIZ: 2008
1. LD joins forces with the local wine blogging talent. A huge thank you to our blogging brethren – Michelle at My Wine Education, Tim Lemke at Cheap Wine Ratings, Mike Rosenberg at The Naked Vine and Jonathan Seeds at Best Drink Ever for opening the floodgates to a whole new audience.
2. Heidelberg Distributing and their Bordeaux Importing. At long last, Bordeaux wines at great prices WITHOUT having to buy them on futures.
3. Kermit Lynch hooks up with Heidelberg Distributing. Finally, after so many years of this extraordinary French/Italian portfolio being locked up in exclusivity, we now have access to the best, most diverse French book in the U.S.
4. Four Vines Comes to KY. After the past two years of the Cincinnati Wine Festival having been blown away by these wines, I am pleased to at last, sell their terrific wines. However, the single-vineyard Zins have yet to arrive so this should rank higher once that happens.
5. TGIC Imports. We have been championing this importer for years, but at long last, I think we have finally gotten the customers in on the act.
6. Malbec Mania hits the stores. We’ve come across a cornucopia of not only great Argentinean Malbec, but fantastic South American wines, making it the largest growing category here at our stores.
7. Jean-Robert’s Restaurants. With Chalk and Greenup Café joining Jean-Robert’s Downtown restaurants, we are seeing more and more customers looking for wines introduced to them by the crack staff at all his restaurants. A big shout out to Bryant, the sommelier at Chalk! It has ushered in an era of great new restaurants being recognized in Northern KY, including newly relocated NuVo, Mainstrasse’s Otto’s and Bouquet, Fort Thomas staple Vito’s Café and the legends Waterfront, Chart House and Mike Fink’s.
8. Layer Cake Diversifies. With the success of their Shiraz (which is currently out of stock), the additions of the Malbec, Primitivo and Cotes du Rhone have taken off, establishing this brand as a recognizable source of quality and value.
9. Enquirer Ads Take Off. Our owner’s serious marketing blitzkrieg has served in getting the word out that we are the area’s low-price wine leader.
10. Columbia Crest Does it Again. The remarkable Two Vines Vineyard 10 Red (currently on the 2006 vintage) has become one of our top-selling value wines of all time. A stunning blend of Sangiovese, Syrah and Cab, this wine overdelivers on everything.
And the worst things that have happened in KY’s wine world are:
1. Republic National Distributing drops the rising star importer Wines of Spain. Aurelio Cabestrero is fast becoming a force to be reckoned with in the Spanish wine market, yet with the nationalizing of their portfolio, RNDC jettisoned one of the best kept secrets in the biz.
2. Republic National Distributing drops Tangent and Baileyana. California’s rising stars from the Edna Valley, Tangent and Baileyana (Tangent was named one of the top value brands of the year in Wine & Spirits), these wines never really had a chance.
3. The continued battle for/against interstate wine shipments here in KY. With these restrictions, the continued dimished availability of many allocated wines (such as Shafer, Peter Michael, Paloma and others) miffs wine buyers and confounds aficionados all over the world.
4. Southern Wine & Spirits and Glazer’s join forces. Bigger isn’t always better and the move towards a distribution monopoly continues. We retailers are faced with a looming prospect of the most abysmal customer service entity in history – aside from Budweiser. Resembling SkyNet of the spirits industry.
5. Exclusivities in the industry continue to perplex consumers. Outdated business models followed by such companies as Kysela, Ex Cellars, Robert Kacher and many other importers bound themselves up in an exclusive agreement with one retailer (out of over 640 in the state), forcing many to either look elsewhere for their French, Italian, Spanish, etc. or drive up to Ohio where, despite there being more readily available, the prices are much higher.
Saturday, December 20, 2008
HE'S MAKING A LIST AND HE'S CHECKING IT TWICE...
And just in time because the redheaded stepchild accoutrement to the WS Top 100 is the Wine Enthusiast Top 100. Couple this one with San Francisco Chronicle's Top 100 (which I would be more apt to be into), and you've got yourself a big list hoedown.
I am just waiting to compare the WS and WE lists this year because last year, someone took on the interesting task of correlating the two lists from 2007, and discovered that there wasn't one wine on both lists. NOT ONE! Don't you find that a bit odd? I don't think there was really any valid explanation than to say that it just worked out that way. Now I am not knocking those findings, I just think it strange.
And speaking of strange lists, I will be posting my own Top Ten at least (I like Dave Letterman's way of doing things) as well as listing our resident wine alien, Alfonse's Top Picks for the Year. We'll have those up next weekend so stay tuned.
Friday, December 19, 2008
WHAT THE NEW SOCIAL MEDIA MEANS FOR US WINOS
What does this mean for wine? There have been a lot of different folks on the Web speak about this new concept of using Facebook, Twitter, Linkedln, Flickr, MySpace, Open Wine Consortium and various other social media web sites as a new means of connecting with current and potential customers, as well as creating a very dynamic, interactive arena in which to exchange thoughts, customer comments, and otherwise engage each other in the conversations of all things wine.
Thanks to folks like Lisa de Bruin (of WineDiverGirl), Steve Heimoff (from the Wine Enthusiast) and Dale Cruse (Drinks Are On Me), the stage is set for a whole new experience in wine discussion and adventure. I've even learned that some retail stores are actually making use of Twitter and other social median as a way of marketing specials, advertising discounts, and engaging their clientele economically, not just socially. That's cool. Here's to the new guerrilla marketing plan.
P.S. Huge thanks to Dale at Drinks Are On Me for listing me amongst all the Twittering winos out there. There's a helluva lot of us now so it's nice to make the list.
Thursday, December 18, 2008
AGING WINES: MYTHS AND FACTS
It’s a common misconception that white wines are meant to drink young and red wines are meant to age. The plain truth of the matter is that 90% of all wine produced, regardless of its tint, is meant to be drank within its first 6 months. It’s that other 10% that has any true aging potential – and that is red, white and sparkling.
Take for example the 1998 vintage (anyone remember this one?) Wine Spectator in particular absolutely murdered the California 1998s, yet consumers just heard the year and assumed everything from that vintage sucked. I was constantly pointing out to customers that 1998 in Australia, Rhone and Oregon were all phenomenal wines, and places like Piedmont and Washington State didn’t fare to badly either. Everything devolves into half-truths and full-blown misconceptions in the press, which is unfortunate. I feel for the real journalists in this business who get misquoted or have their stories taken out of context, yet it’s guys like Laube and Shanken from Spectator that really do the most damage in the long run.
I was inspired, if not outright taught, to look at a producer’s track record, how they can take a so-called bad year, and turn it around for them, make it work FOR them. Chateau Lynch-Bages in Pauillac would be an excellent example. Here is a producer that really doesn’t make a bad wine, even if the vintage is not all that great. It’s the winemaker that take lemons and make lemonade that stand out for me as a buyer, and I have worked for years to convey that in the selections that we offer here in our store.
Nobody’s perfect, that’s for sure, but sometimes wineries such as Lynch-Bages put forth Herculean efforts to create consistently extraordinary wines using all that nature has provided, alongside the natural talent that winemakers such as Daniel Llose and Nicolas Lebenne (the winemaking team at Lynch-Bages) exemplify the point that you must not necessarily look at an overall vintage in order to assess the quality of a particular region, but take into account the presence of great talent.
In getting back to my point about white wines that CAN age and age well, here are a few we currently have in the store:
Philippe Delesvaux Anjou Aunthentique 2005: 5-7 years.
H. Donnhoff Riesling QbA 2007: anywhere from 3-12 years!
Poet’s Leap Riesling Columbia Valley 2007: possibly 7 years.
Fritz Haag Riesling Spatlese Brauneberger Juffer Mosel-Saar-Ruwer 2007: potentially up to 12 years.
Joh. Jos. Cristoffel Erbern Riesling Spatlese Erdener Treppchen Mosel 2007: Quite possibly up to 2030.
Hiedler Gruner Veltliner November 2007: Up to 2017.
You can check out the wines of Nicolas Joly from the Savennieres, or the Vouvray of Phillipe Foreau. There are white Bordeaux, Grand Cru Rieslings from the Alsace (from producers such as Weinback, Marcel Deiss and Kuentz-Bas) that all possess extraordinary aging potential. Look past all the stereotypes and make your own truth.
Wednesday, December 17, 2008
L. AUBRY IVOIRE ET EBENE 2002
Tuesday, December 16, 2008
TORZI MATTHEWS SCHIST ROCK SHIRAZ 2007
Monday, December 15, 2008
PRIELER CHARDONNAY 2007
Sunday, December 14, 2008
HIRSCH GRUNER VELTLINER "VELTLINER #1" 2007
Saturday, December 13, 2008
SETZER RIESLING 2007
Friday, December 12, 2008
COLUMBIA CREST VINEYARD 10 RED 2006
This red blend of primarily Syrah, Sangiovese and Cabernet Sauvignon is medium-bodied, with mild tannins, smooth red and black berry fruit flavors, hints of red plum, cinnamon, mocha and spice notes, and a finish that is quite impressive for the price. Those looking at QPR (quality-price ratio) will see this as a home run. Even in today’s dark economic times, you could still afford to buy this one by the case.
Thursday, December 11, 2008
JOCELYN LONEN CABERNET SAUVIGNON RESERVE 2004
It takes awhile for this one to open up – it’s still quite young. After an hour or so of decanting, the wine is still very shy and introverted. However, after a few hours, the tannin structure is firm and silty, with a strong backbone of acidity and the presence of dense black and blue fruits, cocoa, espresso, cigar box, coffee, Darjeeling tea, cinnamon, and dried herbs. Layers and layers of complexity run throughout this wine, and the finish is long.
500 cases of this elegant, complex red were made, and this is the last vintage before the fruit will find its way into the regular Napa Valley bottling. It will be a great wine for cellaring or for your next big meal of beef tenderloin or roasted lamb.
Wednesday, December 10, 2008
GUSHING FOR CHALK
WINE BLOGGING WEDNESDAY #52: CHILEAN REDS
For a bit of background on Cono Sur, this producer, which is located in the Colchagua Valley of Chile, is striving to become both the top organic wine producer in the Southern Hemisphere, as well as the leading producer of Pinot Noir in South America. With this venture (this joins the already staff favorites entry-level Pinot Noir ($7.98), Vision Pinot Noir ($11.98) and 20 Barrels Pinot Noir ($21.98) that we currently have in our stores.
Cono Sur currently has over 200 acres of Pinot Noir under vine and is all done using sustainable agricultural techniques, employing old world winemaking with state-of-the-art green viticulture.
This particular Pinot Noir is light-bodied, with an almost-cherry red hue. Its grape/cherry bouquet is fragrant and inviting, offering notes of bright berry, candy and cola as well. On the palate, there are more grapey notes, with bright fresh cherries and red raspberries, a bit of pomegranate as well. Also present are just the tiniest glints of spice and menthol, and a nice candied cherry finish. Its juicy, vibrant and has a really nice finish. It would be a nice accompaniment to Pastel de Chocio (beef, chicken and corn pie) – a traditional Chilean dish – or everyday American food such as pizza, pasta and burgers.
Go green with this delicious, inexpensive Pinot Noir. Your palate and your environment will thank you.
Tuesday, December 9, 2008
FIRST LOVE RED 2006
Monday, December 8, 2008
THE FINE ART OF SHAMELESS SELF-PROMOTION
Saturday, December 6, 2008
Weird Pairings Continued...
- Hearty Malbecs with a good steak
- Dry Rieslings with Thai
- Marquis Philips Merlot with the deer huntn' cabin
- Stogies with fishing
- Minerally Pinot Gris with chicken
- Cognac with skiing
- Rose with a ham sandwich
- Good gin with tonic
Remember, never pair a wine with food that you don't like. For example, don't let your wine person sell you a Chardonnay to pair with a meal if you don't even like Chardonnay to begin with. There's no need to suffer through a wine you don't like just because someone told you it would be the "best" pairing. Also, if some snobby wine salesperson says that your palate sucks or is "oh so slightly off", you calmly respond with... "So's your face!"
Friday, December 5, 2008
CLOSEOUTS AND CHILI by Shannon
You may think Greek wines would pair best, given that Skyline originated from Greek recipes. However, the general sweetness of the Greek wines available to the U.S. market don’t lend themselves entirely well to the meat-based spaghetti-hotdog variations.
But what I did try is a wine we currently have on closeout at 2 for $10, Leopards Leap Pinotage Shiraz 2004. A brief lesson on Pinotage: In 1925 two grapes were crossbred in South Africa, Pinot Noir and Cinsault. Although both French varietals, the wine produced seems nothing like its parents. Usually a wine with given characteristics of bramble, earth and tropical fruits, this wine didn’t really hit the U.S. market until the late 90’s.
Unexpectedly, this South African wine was a perfect match for my dinner last night, Skyline Chili (probably my favorite food, anyway.) Filled with plenty of fruit and chocolate notes, it brought out the elusive ingredients in Skyline, chocolate and cinnamon. Basically, a Greek man brought his chili recipe to Cincinnati in the 40’s, a South African wine hit the Cincinnati market in the 90’s, and here I am, a German-Irish gal enjoying them together. Isn’t globalization a crazy thing?
Basically, the moral of the story is to try new wines with your favorite foods all the time, and who knows, you just might get lucky and find a great pairing.
Thursday, December 4, 2008
AMAZING WHAT PASSES FOR CUSTOMER SERVICE THESE DAYS
But what struck me as hilarious was the visit to one of our competitor's I must say, and his confrontation with one of the wine staff. Mike was looking for a rose, one that wasn't too acidic, and the wine person there told him they didn't carry it and they WOULDN'T CARRY IT. Mike asked why and the person told him it wasn't acidic enough to be a real rose. When Mike said that is what he liked in a rose, the person basically came out and told him he had an inferior palate, berated him in the middle of the store and stormed off.
Ha! I thought, Damn! What balls! I know if that person worked for us, he wouldn't be working for us no more. Customer service is huge in this business because wine is such a community thing. People love to tell other people about what wine they had last night with dinner, or what wine suggestion they got from the wine store down the street. Oh, and did you see that Chateau XYZ just got 91 points in Spectator, and it's only $10!
You get the idea.
I'm glad Mike shops with us now, but regardless of where he or anyone else shops, the object of all of this is that you find good people at a place you feel comfortable with, whether it's Piazza Discepoli in Cincinnati, Eric Jerardi's Little Store up in Vandalia, Mary Kay at The Winds Wine Store way up in Yellow Springs, or Gordo down at Old Town in Louisville. The people there at the wine stores you go to are there for YOU! They may have SUGGESTIONS but they are there to service YOUR NEEDS and YOUR LIKES. That's what it's all about. And it doesn't require a Ph.D. to understand that.
Wednesday, December 3, 2008
A BRIEF LOOK AT BORDEAUX PART THREE
First let me lay out the Classification of Sauternes and Barsac:
Premier Cru Superieur (First Great Growth)
Chateau d’Yquem
Premier Crus (First Growths)
Chateau Climens
Chateau Coutet
Chateau Clos Haut-Peyraguey
Chateau de Rayne-Vigneau
Chateau Guiraud
Chateau Lafaurie-Peyraguey
Chateau La Tour Blanche
Chateau Rabaud-Promis
Chateau Rieussec
Chateau Sigalas-Rabaud
Chateau Suduiraut
Deuxiemes Crus (Second Growths)
Chateau Broustet
Chateau Caillou
Chateau d’Arche
Chateau de Malle
Chateau de Myrat
Chateau Doisy-Daene
Chateau Doisy-Dubroca
Chateau Doisy-Vedrines
Chateau Filhot
Chateau Lamothe-Despujols
Chateau Lamote-Guignard
Chateau Nairac
Chateau Romer
Chateau Romer-du-Hayot
Chateau Suau
Obviously, the most prestigious of these chateaux is d’Yquem, the ultimate in luxury. However, wines from Chateaux Guiraud, Rieussec and Suduiraut have become highly sought after wines, with many critics feeling that these producers have equaled or perhaps even surpassed the stature of d’Yquem.
If you aren’t wanting to spend a lot of money, yet still want to experience the beauty of the botrytis cinera, you may want to investigate Loupiac, an appellation which lies on the opposite bank of the Garonne River, directly across from Sauternes and Barsac. Loupiac turns out terrific botrytisized whites without the hefty price tag. Also look into Monbazillac, the area in the Dordogne that emulates Barsac, yet is a mere fraction of its cost.
Finally, there are two terms anyone new to Bordeaux should be aware of – Cru Bourgeois and Bordeaux Superieur. The term Cru Bourgeois refers to the approximately 200 chateaux that were not part of the classification of 1855. These have for many years been viewed upon by critics as being somewhat inferior to the Classified Growths, yet nonetheless good values. However, with innovations in winemaking techniques and more modern technologies at these winemakers’ disposal, many of these once-inferior chateaux are now exceptionally well-made, and at a fraction of what the classified growths cost. Wines from such chateaux as Chasse-Spleen, Sociando-Mallet, Maucaillou, Potensac and Poujeaux are extremely good values and much easier to find.
Bordeaux Superieur refers to wines from what have been deemed less than desirable areas within Bordeaux. However, as with the Cru Bourgeois, these wines have become much more affordable alternatives to the Classified Growths – such as Chateaux Pey La Tour, Haut-Nadeau and Fleur de Rigaud.
I hope that this information has helped you in discovering a bit of what Bordeaux has to offer. I urge you to check out my friend Eric Jerardi’s entertaining DVD, Get Real Wine Volume II: Bordeaux, as well as visit http://www.bordeaux.com/ for more information on this fantastic wine region.
A votre santé!
Tuesday, December 2, 2008
A BRIEF LOOK AT BORDEAUX PART TWO
First, let’s outline the Classification of 1855:
Chateau Lafite-Rothschild, Pauillac
Chateau Latour, Pauillac
Chateau Margaux, Margaux
Chateau Mouton-Rothschild, Pauillac
Chateau Brane-Cantenac, Margaux
Chateau Cos d’Estournel, St.-Estephe
Chateau Ducru-Beaucaillou, St.-Julien
Chateau Durfort-Vivens, Margaux
Chateau Gruaud-Larose, St.-Julien
Chateau Lascombes, Margaux
Chateau Leoville-Barton, St.-Julien
Chateau Leoville-Las-Cases, St.-Julien
Chateau Leoville-Poyferre, St.-Julien
Chateau Montrose, St.-Estephe
Chateau Pichon-Longueville-Baron, Pauillac
Chateau Pichon-Longueville-Comtesse-de-Lalande, Pauillac
Chateau Rauzan-Segla, Margaux
Chateau Rauzan-Gassies, Margaux
Third Growths
Chateau Boyd-Cantenac, Margaux
Chateau Calon-Segur, St.-Estephe
Chateau Cantenac-Brown, Margaux
Chateau Desmirail, Margaux
Chateau d’Issan, Margaux
Chateau Ferriere, Margaux
Chateau Giscours, Margaux
Chateau Kirwan, Margaux
Chateau Lagrange, St.-Julien
Chateau La Lagune, Haut-Medoc
Chateau Langoa-Barton, St.-Julien
Chateau Malescot-St.-Exupery, Margaux
Chateau Marquis d’Alesme-Becker, Margaux
Chateau Palmer, Margaux
Fourth Growths
Chateau Beycheville, St.-Julien
Chateau Branaire-Ducru, St.-Julien
Chateau Duhart-Milon-Rothschild, Pauillac
Chateau Lafon Rochet, St.-Estephe
Chateau la Tour-Carnet, Haut-Medoc
Chateau Marquis de-Terme, Margaux
Chateau Pouget, Margaux
Chateau Prieure-Lichine, Margaux
Chateau St.-Pierre, St.-Julien
Chateau Talbot, St.-Julien
Fifth Growths
Chateau Batailley, Pauillac
Chateau Belgrave, Haut-Medoc
Chateau Cantemerle, Haut-Medoc
Chateau Clerc-Milon, Pauillac
Chateau Cos Labory, St.-Estephe
Chateau Croizet-Bages, Pauillac
Chateau d’Armailhac, Pauillac
Chateau Dauzac, Margaux
Chateau du Carmensac, Haut-Medoc
Chateau du Tertre, Margaux
Chateau Grand-Puy-Ducasse, Pauillac
Chateau Grand-Puy-Lacoste, Pauillac
Chateau Haut-Bages-Liberal, Pauillac
Chateau Haut-Batailley, Pauillac
Chateau Lynch-Bages, Pauillac
Chateau Lynch-Moussas, Pauillac
Chateau Pedesclaux, Pauillac
Chateau Pontet-Canet, Pauillac
Obviously, the prestigious ones are the first growths, yet there are some terrific wines to be had in the other four classifications. The standouts are almost always (vintage after vintage): Leoville Las Cases (2nd growth), Cos d’Estournel (2nd growth), Lascombes (2nd growth), Pichon-Longueville-Comtesse de Lalande (2nd growth), Malescot-St.-Exupery (3rd growth), Beychevelle (4th growth), Prieure-Lichine (4th growth), Clerc-Milon (5th growth), d’Armailhac (5th growth) and Lynch Bages (5th growth). In past vintages, these wines were (and still are to some degree) a fraction of what the 1st growths cost, however, these wines, as the word gets out, are becoming more-and-more expensive.
Some rising stars for value are Chateau Sociando-Mallet and Senejac (both Haut-Medoc). These unclassified chateaux are exceptional values. Parker even argues that Sociando-Mallet should become a 5th growth wine.
For Right Bank wines, St.-Emilion are classified, yet the top two – Chateau Cheval Blanc and Chateau Ausone – are typically astronomically priced. It’s difficult to find a good St.-Emilion out there for under $100 (Cheval Blanc and Ausone usually come in around $1200/bottle!), but they are out there. One particular St.-Emilion we carry that is superbly affordable is the Chateau St.-Georges St.-Georges St.-Emilion, which lies just outside the city of St.-Emilion.
And of course, the super rarity, that being Pomerol, is not classified at all. The tiniest commune in all of Bordeaux, wines like Petrus, Le Pin, Lafleur and Vieux-Chateau-Certan are equally pricy, topping out these days between $800 and $1200 per bottle. Their small production and amazing cellarability make these wines highly sought after the world over.
Also, look for wines produced by or consulted on by enologists such as Michel Rolland (subject of the documentary Mondovino) and Jonathan Malthus, or negociants like Andre Lurton and Dourthe. These individuals or groups usually deal with multiple Chateaux and make sure that quality is high and accessibility is good.
Tomorrow, I’ll wrap things up with a look at the sweeter side of Bordeaux, as well as the peripheral region of the Dordogne.
Monday, December 1, 2008
A BRIEF LOOK AT BORDEAUX PART ONE
Lately, I have become enamored with all things Bordeaux. Obviously I picked a good time to really fall in love with Bordeaux – with the 2005 vintage, the wines were across the board incredible – though prices were astronomical. In light of that, Liquor Direct kicks off its first ever Bordeaux sale, one I hope we can repeat. And in honor of the event, I’d like to offer up a primer for those who want to learn more about these incredible wines, yet not invest a few years trying to decipher all the ins-and-outs of the region and its beautiful wines.
First off, let’s talk about the region of Bordeaux. The province of Bordeaux sits on the western Atlantic shores of France, in the southwesternly portion of the country. The town of Bordeaux sits at the mouth of the Gironde river, the body of water which separates the region into two distinct parts – the Left Bank and the Right Bank. The predominant number of communes (villages) lie within the Left Bank, while the Right Bank possesses primarily 2 communes (Pomerol and St.-Emilion).
Second, the grape varieties are set in stone: for whites, the grapes are Sauvignon Blanc, Semillon, Muscadelle, and to a lesser extent, Ugni Blanc. And for the reds, the grapes are Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Cabernet Franc, Malbec and Petit Verdot.
When we in the business talk about Bordeaux, we often speak of the different Chateaux (wine houses) as either Left- or Right-Bank in style. The predominant grape in Left Bank reds is Cabernet Sauvignon, while Right-Bank usually boasts a majority of Merlot (although the commune of St.-Emilion does at times emphasize Cabernet Franc, such as Chateau Cheval Blanc). With the whites, Sauvignon Blanc is used primarily in the still wines, while Semillon tends to be the dominant grape used in the Sauternes and Barsac wines.
The lesser known aspect of the Bordeaux geography is that the Gironde divides into two smaller estuaries – the Garonne and the Dordogne. The land that stretches between these two smaller rivers is known as the Entre-Deux-Mers (between two seas). It is in this area that one finds the Loupiac (viewed by many as a sort-of poor man’s Sauternes, a real value). The Loupiac lies just across the banks of the Garonne from the Sauternes, Barsac and Ceron.
So let’s delve in a bit further, shall we?
THE LEFT BANK
From north to south, the communes are as follows:
1. The Northern Medoc
A. St.-Estephe
B. Pauillac
C. St.-Julien
2. Central Medoc
A. Listrac-Medoc
B. Moulis-en-Medoc
3. The Southern Medoc: Margaux
4. Graves and Entre-Deux-Mers
A. Barsac
B. Cadillac
C. Cerons
D. Entre-Deux-Mers
E. Graves
F. Loupiac
G. Pessac-Leognan
H. Sauternes
THE RIGHT BANK
From north to south, the communes are as follows:
1. Libournais
A. Fronsac
B. Canon-Fronsac
C. Lalande-de-Pomerol
D. Pomerol
E. St.-Emilion
F. Cotes du Castillon
G. Montagne-St.-Emilion
H. Lussac-St.-Emilion
I. St.-Georges-St.-Emilion
2. Dordogne
A. Cotes de Francs
B. Montravel
C. Haut-Montravel
D. Bergerac
E. Cotes de Duras
F. Monbazillac
G. Pecharmant
H. Rousette
I. Saussignac
Sunday, November 30, 2008
IT ALL COMES DOWN TO YOU
The difference between rating wines and assessing their market appeal are two entirely different animals, if only in the fact that you have to look at the wine's QPR (quality-price ratio) and any other nuances that might be appealing to consumers - like limited availability or direct import or regionality, there are a host of variables.
Buying by the numbers is almost an inherent indication that the buyer (for a wine store, restaurant, etc.) is without any real palate or knowledge of their own. It's something I have learned over the years, thanks in large part to a great many individuals I have come to respect and admire - not only for their palates, but for their passion and desire for this business and for wine itself. My buddy Eric Jerardi was one who I feel unintentionally coerced me into exploring my own palate as I was building my first wine list at Cafe Boulevard in Dayton, Ohio (while I was bar manager there). People like Mary Kay at The Winds in Yellow Springs and the late, great Doug Simon of Arrow Wine & Spirits, who had a fairly innovative approach to how they selected wines for their respective stores. So many people I have met and worked either for or with over the years, have contributed to my own wine education, and I continue to learn each day.
Yet it is ironically, the artist in me that seeks out the unique, artistic expression in a wine before I really consider it for the store. As far as the scores go, I am unimpressed. The worst thing a winemaker or an importer can do when pitching a wine to me is bringing up the scores it received FIRST. Right there, that is a tell that the wine sucks and they can't sell it. A wine should be something that is almost too intangible to describe YET THEY FIND A WAY ANYWAY.
A great example is the first time I tried Verite - a big boy Sonoma blend from wine mastermind Jess Jackson. I was introduced to the first vintage - the 1998 - by way of an old friend, Rich Collins, who was working for Corterra Brands (the brokerage representing Verite, as well as Stonestreet, Cambria, and others - it's now called Majestic Wines). Sitting in the store with him and the brand manager - whose name escapes me right now - and tasting the wine, there wasn't a great deal of bantering. No need - the wine was ethereal. I actually told him it reminded me of a poem I continue to herald as one of my faves, by Pablo Neruda, called "Body of a Woman." One of the most sensuous works of the modern era, and the poem was pretty seductive too.
Years later, I was able to revisit the wine upon my visit to the winery with my wife. At this point, the wine was 8 years old. And it was even more remarkable than when I first tasted it. It literally stopped time.
Granted, this is a pretty exaggerated example, but you get the point. What speaks to me as a buyer is what's in the bottle. An Aussie blend that rocks, and it's under $10 - bring it on! A Bordeaux Superieur from a great vintage that drinks like a classified growth, and I can sell it for under $20. Rock on!
The point is that while everyone is up-in-arms over Wine Spectator and Robert Parker, the crux of the matter is that these guys are no different in being able to assess the quality of a wine than YOU are. Sure they have their magazines and their subscribers, but in the end, it's all about YOU. They could just as easily score Chateau Whatsits 2008 a 100-point wine, but you could buy it, try it, and think it positively sucks. That's just the way it is - taste is subjective. Only yours counts in the end.
And they don't really want you to realize that. Once you do, then you won't give a crap about anything they say.